3.3 Team Reflection and Presenting
Collecting honest reflection material all season, the final check before submission, and preparing students to present.
Part 1 of 5 What the Reflection Is For
The Team Reflection closes the Final Report. It explains how the team's research, collaboration, disagreements, decisions and learning shaped its recommendation.
The 2026 instructions asked for the whole competition experience and told teams not to repeat the Trading Notes Analysis. One of the five criteria, the articulation of the competition experience, reads this part closely. Wharton's FAQ asks teams to communicate their reasoning and experience "clearly and authentically."
A judge who reads hundreds of reports can tell a real story from a polished one.
Part 2 of 5 Collect Moments All Season
The best reflections come from notes taken during the season. Make it a routine: at the end of each meeting, every student writes one line about a moment that mattered.
- A disagreement and how the team settled it.
- A decision that changed, and the evidence that changed it.
- Research that mattered more than expected.
- A mistake, what it cost, and what the team does differently now.
- Something that surprised them about markets or the client.
In December the students sort their lines into themes, one heading per theme. Push for specifics. "We learned a lot about teamwork" fits any report. "Two of us wanted a 10 percent stock position; the vote went 4 to 2 for 5 percent, because our IPS capped single stocks" fits only one.
Part 3 of 5 The Final Check
Give the team a checklist built from its year's instructions and a full read-through meeting before submission. In 2026 the list covered at least:
- Every section present and inside its page range.
- A title page matching the official roster exactly, including your name.
- A holdings table listing every final holding, every one permitted, with totals that tie out.
- Projections built from the case's figures with no WInS gains or losses.
- A heading for every required recommendation element.
- Nothing that contradicts the IPS.
- Font, spacing, margins, page numbers, APA references and AI citations as required.
- Every sentence written by a member of the team.
The team leader submits a day early through the official form, and someone confirms it went through.
Part 4 of 5 Preparing to Present
Wharton picks 50 semifinal teams from the written work. In recent years the semifinals were held online, and the top ten teams presented at the Global Finale in Philadelphia. Each round is a short presentation on the team's strategy, analysis and experience to a live panel of judges, and Wharton's FAQ says all team members must participate. Check the current rules for the format, time limit and dates.
| Step | What the team does |
|---|---|
| Lead with the client | Opens with who the client is and what they need |
| Answer early | States the recommendation and its main numbers in the first minute |
| Know the numbers | Every member can explain the safe rate, the allocation and the range |
| Practice questions | Teammates or invited staff play judges and attack the fit between client and plan |
| Share the stage | Every member has a planned part |
Coach students to answer with evidence: the case sentence, the IPS rule or the scenario row behind a choice. When they do not know, they say so and explain how they would find out.
Part 5 of 5 Questions to Ask Your Team
- What disagreement changed our recommendation, and how was it settled?
- Which line in the reflection could appear in any other team's report?
- Who has checked the title page against the roster?
- If a judge asks why we hold this, which case sentence and IPS rule do we point to?
Key Terms
Practice Questions
4 questions. Nothing here is recorded or scored.
- Question 1
A student's reflection paragraph reads, "Our team worked well together and learned a lot." What do you ask?
- A."Would you like me to suggest what you learned?"
- B."Can you list your three trading notes instead?"
- C."Can you make it sound more professional?"
- D."What is one moment from your notes, a vote, an argument or a changed decision, that shows this?"
Check answerHide answer
Answer: D
- A.
- The reflection must be the students' own account.
- B.
- The 2026 instructions said not to repeat the Trading Notes Analysis.
- C.
- Polish without specifics still says nothing.
- D.
- Correct. The question sends the student back to real material.
- Question 2
Two weeks before the deadline, the team wants you to write the reflection because "you saw everything." What do you say?
- A.Tell them to skip the reflection
- B.Agree, since you watched every meeting
- C.Decline, and hand back the moment lines they wrote each week so they can build it themselves
- D.Agree, if they edit it afterward
Check answerHide answer
Answer: C
- A.
- The Team Reflection was a required part of the 2026 report.
- B.
- Work cannot be copied from any source, including advisors.
- C.
- Correct. You support with their own material; they write.
- D.
- Editing your draft still leaves it your work.
- Question 3
Which plan best prepares a team for the semifinal presentation?
- A.The strongest speaker presents alone
- B.Every member has a planned part, the recommendation comes first, and the team rehearses hard questions
- C.The team reads the Final Report aloud
- D.The team focuses on its WInS ranking
Check answerHide answer
Answer: B
- A.
- Wharton's FAQ says all team members must participate.
- B.
- Correct. That meets the participation rule and prepares the team for the panel.
- C.
- Judges have read it; they want the strategy explained and defended.
- D.
- WInS standings have little to do with the outcome.
- Question 4
In a practice round, a student answers a question with "Treasuries always do well." What feedback helps?
- A."Which case fact and which IPS rule led us to hold them?"
- B."Say your advisor recommended them"
- C."Avoid that question"
- D."Good answer"
Check answerHide answer
Answer: A
- A.
- Correct. It teaches the student to answer with evidence.
- B.
- Advisors may not make strategy decisions, and judges want the team's reasoning.
- C.
- Students cannot choose the judges' questions.
- D.
- Treasury prices move with interest rates, and the answer ignores the client.