Unit 1 Free-Response Practice
Nettlefield Trailer Works
8 points total
Nettlefield Trailer Works
Acting as an outside adviser, you will help the business in the scenario below choose between two courses of action.
Nettlefield Trailer Works builds steel cargo trailers that hitch to the back of a bicycle. Margo Osterhout started the business in her garage in Sable Ridge, Wisconsin, in 2016. Nettlefield now has twenty six employees, fourteen of them skilled welders, and sells its trailers through eighty five independent bike shops in five Midwestern states. The shops buy each trailer for $430 and set their own retail prices. Nettlefield states that its core values are durability, summed up in its motto "built to outlast the bike," and fair dealing with the shops that sell its trailers.
Nettlefield holds a patent on its quick release hitch, which lets a rider attach or remove the trailer in under ten seconds. The patent expires in four years.
Two years ago a regional chain of bike shops closed, and Nettlefield lost orders for about nine hundred trailers a year. Sales fell from 4,100 trailers to 3,200 last year. The plant can build 5,000 trailers a year, so more than a third of it now sits idle. Osterhout wants to put that unused capacity to work, and she has narrowed her choices to two courses of action.
City Fleet Proposal: build a heavy duty trailer for city programs. Three city governments have asked for bids on heavy duty trailers for their bike share and parcel delivery programs. Nettlefield would redesign its trailer with a stronger frame and pass a city safety certification, which would take ten months. The cities would buy about 1,200 trailers a year at $610 each under three year contracts, and riders and couriers would use the trailers as part of the city programs. Only two other companies hold the certification today. Each contract must be approved in a city council budget vote every year, and one of the three cities cut its transit budget last spring. The new trailer uses the same welding skills, so all fourteen welders could build it after one week of training, and no new staff would be hired.
Direct Sales Proposal: sell online to riders across the country. Nettlefield would build a website, rent warehouse space, and sign with a shipping company to sell its current trailer directly to riders nationwide for $649. It projects online sales of about 700 trailers a year, and the website could open in four months. Fourteen other brands already sell cargo trailers online, and several imported trailers sell for $299. Nettlefield would hire three new employees for marketing and customer service. In a survey, thirty one of the eighty five shops said they would stop carrying Nettlefield trailers if Nettlefield sold online at a price close to theirs. Those thirty one shops bought 1,150 of last year's 3,200 trailers. The return on investment projection in Figure 1 does not count any lost shop orders.
Financial summary: Osterhout has $250,000 in cash to put toward the one time cost of either proposal and would borrow the rest. Figure 1 summarizes the two proposals.
| Figure 1 | City Fleet Proposal | Direct Sales Proposal |
|---|---|---|
| One time cost | $480,000 | $300,000 |
| Cash on hand applied | $250,000 | $250,000 |
| Additional funds to borrow | $230,000 | $50,000 |
| Projected annual return on investment | 18% | 24% |
| Projected new trailers sold per year | 1,200 | 700 |
| Price per trailer | $610 | $649 |
| Projected new revenue per year | $732,000 | $454,300 |
| Months until first sale | 10 | 4 |
| Rival sellers in the new market | 2 | 14 |
| New employees needed | 0 | 3 |
This is a self-check. You compare your answers with the sample answers and the rubric, and you decide which points you earned. Your answers stay in this browser.
Nettlefield's choice is shaped by conditions inside the business, in its market, and in the wider environment.
0 / 1,500
0 / 1,500
Compare the City Fleet Proposal and the Direct Sales Proposal using the three criteria below. For each one, describe a difference or a similarity and give specific evidence for both proposals.
0 / 1,500
0 / 1,500
0 / 1,500
Recommend either the City Fleet Proposal or the Direct Sales Proposal. State which proposal you recommend, explain why it is the better choice for Nettlefield, and back up your choice with three specific criteria, each with evidence from the scenario. Criteria from part B may be used again, and other financial or nonfinancial criteria are also allowed. Part C is worth 3 points, so it has three boxes here, one for each point.
0 / 1,500
0 / 1,500
0 / 1,500