Skip to content

6.1 Socially Efficient and Inefficient Market Outcomes

Social efficiency where marginal benefit equals marginal cost, how private incentives lead to inefficient outcomes, and measuring deadweight loss.

Part 1 of 4 What Social Efficiency Means

An outcome has social efficiency when it produces the quantity that gives society the largest possible total economic surplus. The optimal quantity of a good is the one where the last unit's marginal benefit to its buyer equals its marginal cost to produce.

Garden centers in the Larkin Valley sell bagged compost in a perfectly competitive market. The demand curve shows buyers' marginal benefit (MB), and the supply curve shows sellers' marginal cost (MC). The curves cross at 12,000 bags a month at $18 a bag. At that quantity, total surplus is 1/2 x ($30 - $6) x 12,000 = $144,000 a month, the most this market can produce.

The competitive equilibrium is efficient here because buyers and sellers bear every benefit and cost of each bag. The market quantity matches the socially optimal quantity only when the people in the market internalize all of the social benefits and costs.

Part 2 of 4 When Private Choices Go Wrong

Rational buyers and sellers act on their own costs and benefits. Rational agents make their best decisions by equating private marginal benefit with private marginal cost, and that can leave a market inefficient. Rational agents can also act to gain or use market power, such as a firm that buys out its rivals and then restricts output.

Situations that pull equilibrium away from the efficient quantity
SituationWhat goes wrong
Monopoly, oligopoly or monopolistic competitionFirms with market power set price above marginal cost and produce too little
Negative externality in production or consumptionA cost falls on outsiders, so the market produces too much
Positive externality in production or consumptionA benefit goes to outsiders, so the market produces too little
Asymmetric informationOne side of a trade knows more than the other, so some valuable trades never happen
Public goodsPeople can benefit without paying, so private firms produce too little

Each of these is a market failure: the market, left alone, produces a quantity other than the efficient one.

Part 3 of 4 Measuring Deadweight Loss

A market graph for compost. Marginal benefit falls from thirty dollars and marginal cost rises from six dollars. They cross at 12,000 bags and eighteen dollars, the efficient quantity. At an output of 8,000 bags, marginal benefit is twenty-two dollars and marginal cost is fourteen dollars, and the triangle between them from 8,000 to 12,000 bags is a deadweight loss of sixteen thousand dollars
Example numbers. Producing 8,000 bags leaves $16,000 of surplus unclaimed.

Producing any quantity other than the efficient one creates deadweight loss, the surplus lost because the wrong quantity is made. Suppose a supply problem limits Larkin Valley sales to 8,000 bags. The 8,000th bag is worth $22 to a buyer and costs $14 to make, so every bag from 8,000 to 12,000 would have added surplus. The deadweight loss is the triangle 1/2 x ($22 - $14) x 4,000 = $16,000.

Producing too much loses surplus too. At 16,000 bags, the last bag costs $22 to make and is worth only $14 to a buyer, and the deadweight loss is again 1/2 x $8 x 4,000 = $16,000.

Part 4 of 4 Fixing Inefficiency

Policymakers use cost-benefit analysis to compare actions that reduce or remove market inefficiency. A policy is worth adopting when the surplus it recovers is larger than its cost. Inefficiency disappears when a policy brings marginal social benefit and marginal social cost into equality at the quantity produced.

Efficiency means producing every unit worth more than it costs, and no unit that costs more than it is worth.

Key Terms

Practice Questions

6 questions. Nothing here is recorded or scored.

  1. Question 1POL-2.A.1

    A Bread Market

    The table shows the marginal benefit and marginal cost of bread in a small town, with no externalities.

    Quantity (thousand loaves) | Marginal benefit | Marginal cost 1 | $20 | $4 2 | $17 | $6 3 | $14 | $8 4 | $11 | $11 5 | $8 | $14 6 | $5 | $17 What is the socially efficient quantity of bread?

    • A.1 thousand loaves
    • B.4 thousand loaves
    • C.6 thousand loaves
    • D.3 thousand loaves
    Check answer

    Answer: B

    A.
    At 1 thousand loaves, marginal benefit ($20) is far above marginal cost ($4), so producing more adds surplus.
    B.
    Correct. The efficient quantity is where the marginal benefit of the last unit equals its marginal cost. At 4 thousand loaves, both equal $11, and total surplus is as large as it can be.
    C.
    At 6 thousand loaves, marginal cost ($17) is above marginal benefit ($5), so the last units destroy surplus.
    D.
    At 3 thousand loaves, marginal benefit ($14) is still above marginal cost ($8), so one more unit adds surplus.
  2. Question 2POL-2.C.2

    Firewood in Selby

    In the market for firewood in the region of Selby, demand is P = 50 - Q and supply is P = 10 + Q, where Q is thousands of bundles per month. Buyers and sellers bear all of the benefits and costs of each bundle.

    A supply disruption limits sales to 14 thousand bundles a month. What is the deadweight loss?

    • A.$72,000
    • B.$18,000
    • C.$144,000
    • D.$36,000
    Check answer

    Answer: D

    A.
    $72,000 omits the one half in the triangle formula: $12 x 6 thousand.
    B.
    $18,000 uses half of the price gap as the height. The height is the full gap between marginal benefit and marginal cost at 14 thousand bundles.
    C.
    $144,000 multiplies the $24 marginal cost by 6 thousand bundles. Deadweight loss is the triangle between marginal benefit and marginal cost.
    D.
    Correct. The efficient quantity is where 50 - Q = 10 + Q, so Q = 20 thousand. At 14 thousand, marginal benefit is $36 and marginal cost is $24. Deadweight loss = 1/2 x ($36 - $24) x 6 thousand = $36,000.
  3. Question 3POL-2.A.2

    When does the equilibrium quantity in a competitive market equal the socially optimal quantity?

    • A.When buyers and sellers bear every social benefit and cost of the good
    • B.Whenever the market has many buyers and many sellers of the good
    • C.When the government sets the price of the good
    • D.When producers in the market earn zero economic profit
    Check answer

    Answer: A

    A.
    Correct. The market quantity is optimal only when the people trading bear every social benefit and cost. Then demand shows marginal social benefit and supply shows marginal social cost, and total surplus is maximized.
    B.
    Many buyers and sellers are not enough. A competitive market with an externality still produces the wrong quantity.
    C.
    A government-set price can push quantity away from the efficient level.
    D.
    Zero profit is a long-run feature of competitive markets, but external costs or benefits can still make the quantity inefficient.
  4. Question 4POL-2.C.1

    Which situation is most likely to lead to an inefficient market outcome?

    • A.Many farmers sell identical wheat to many buyers, and no one outside the market is affected.
    • B.A competitive bakery market adjusts after a rise in the price of flour.
    • C.A used-car seller knows a car has a hidden defect, and buyers cannot detect it.
    • D.Free entry drives economic profit to zero in a perfectly competitive industry.
    Check answer

    Answer: C

    A.
    A perfectly competitive market with no externalities produces where marginal benefit equals marginal cost.
    B.
    A cost increase changes the equilibrium, and the competitive market still settles where marginal benefit equals marginal cost.
    C.
    Correct. This is asymmetric information: one side knows more than the other. Buyers who cannot tell good cars from bad ones may refuse to pay what a good car is worth, so some valuable trades never happen.
    D.
    Zero long-run profit in perfect competition comes with price equal to marginal cost, an efficient outcome.
  5. Question 5POL-2.B.3, POL-2.B.4

    Lawmakers study a rule that would cost firms $2 million a year to follow and would recover $5 million a year of surplus lost to a market inefficiency. Using cost-benefit analysis, what should they conclude?

    • A.Reject the rule, because it raises firms' costs.
    • B.Adopt the rule, because the surplus it recovers is larger than its cost.
    • C.Reject the rule, because any intervention creates deadweight loss.
    • D.Adopt the rule only if it removes the inefficiency entirely.
    Check answer

    Answer: B

    A.
    Raising costs alone is not a reason to reject a policy. The test compares the benefit with the cost.
    B.
    Correct. Policymakers use cost-benefit analysis to evaluate actions that reduce market inefficiencies. The rule adds $5 million of surplus at a cost of $2 million, a net gain of $3 million a year.
    C.
    A well-designed intervention can reduce deadweight loss by moving the market toward the quantity where marginal social benefit equals marginal social cost.
    D.
    A policy that recovers more surplus than it costs is worth adopting even if some inefficiency remains.
  6. Question 6POL-2.C.2, POL-2.B.2

    Firewood in Selby

    In the market for firewood in the region of Selby, demand is P = 50 - Q and supply is P = 10 + Q, where Q is thousands of bundles per month. Buyers and sellers bear all of the benefits and costs of each bundle.

    Suppose a subsidy pushes output to 26 thousand bundles a month. Which statement is correct?

    • A.Total surplus rises, because more firewood is sold.
    • B.There is no deadweight loss, because buyers pay less than before.
    • C.Deadweight loss arises only when output is below the efficient quantity.
    • D.Deadweight loss arises, since bundles past 20 thousand cost more than buyers value them.
    Check answer

    Answer: D

    A.
    Total surplus falls, because each bundle past the efficient quantity of 20 thousand adds more cost than benefit.
    B.
    Lower prices for buyers do not remove the loss. The units past 20 thousand cost more than they are worth.
    C.
    Producing any quantity other than the efficient one creates deadweight loss, whether output is too low or too high.
    D.
    Correct. Beyond 20 thousand bundles, marginal cost is above marginal benefit. At 26 thousand, MC is $36 and MB is $24, so the deadweight loss is 1/2 x $12 x 6 thousand = $36,000.

Practice every topic in Unit 6

CED Codes

POL-2.A.1 · POL-2.A.2 · POL-2.B.1 · POL-2.B.2 · POL-2.B.3 · POL-2.B.4 · POL-2.C.1 · POL-2.C.2