Skip to content

Wharton Advisor Guide

Lesson 3

How to Analyze the Case Study

Read a client case in four passes and end with one sentence.

Practice on a Practice Case

  • The video teaches the method on a practice case written for teaching. It is not a Wharton case.
  • The client is Elias Varnholt, a veterinarian. Elias and every number in his case are invented.
  • Wharton’s rules page bans plagiarism. Practice the method on this case, then do your own analysis of your own case.

Start With One Line

  • Put the whole case in one line first. Look for the one promise the client has to keep. Every other fact in the case relates to that promise.
  • For Elias the line reads: pay his partner $840,000, in cash, on 1 October 2031.
  • Then read the case four times, once for each pass.
  • Read it as evidence. Skip the story.

Four Passes

Practice case. Point to the sentence for every item.
PassWhat to doWhat it finds
The clientSplit a page into the facts and what each tells an analyst.Elias did not sell in the last hard fall, so his willingness to take a loss is high. He says the buyout money cannot come up short, so he cannot afford a loss on it.
The moneyPut every dollar and every date on one timeline.$1.1 million now. $40,000 out in August 2027. About $150,000 in from a land sale, no earlier than Year 2 and maybe never. $840,000 out on 1 October 2031. Income from October 2042.
The mustsList every sentence with must, required, may not or a high degree of confidence. Count them.The practice case has eight. Examples: pay in full and on time, and do not count the land money until it arrives.
The fencesList everything the case says is not the team’s job.Valuing the practice and managing his retirement account. Work on those items takes time away from the team’s own job.

If you cannot point to the sentence, it is not a constraint.

Price the Promise

What $840,000 in five years costs today, at one safe rate
Safe rateCost today
0 percent$840,000
2 percent$760,800
3 percent$724,600
4 percent$690,400
5 percent$658,200
  • The safer the team makes the buyout money, the more of the portfolio it takes.
  • The case names three assumptions, including 2.5 percent inflation. It gives no safe rate.
  • The team picks a rate, defends it, and writes down what changes if it is wrong.

Two Jobs in One Portfolio

  • The case never says what the rest of the money is for. The team has to notice.
  • This portfolio does two jobs with opposite needs.
  • Job one is the buyout money. It must be there, close to certain, in five years. The same bucket holds the $50,000 cash floor and the $40,000 gift to his daughter.
  • Job two is the rest. It has sixteen years to grow toward his retirement, so it can take a bad year.
  • Lining up safe money against a known payment is called liability matching. Two buckets is a fine name for it too.

The Working Session

  1. Build the timeline.
  2. Count the musts and compare lists.
  3. Price the promise at one safe rate you can defend.
  4. Draw the buckets at two or three dates, showing how much is already safe money.
  5. Write the thesis in one sentence.

Thesis shape: Because ___ needs ___ by ___ and can risk ___, we will hold ___ for ___, avoiding ___, because ___.

The Exit Ticket

  • How much money goes in, and when?
  • What must the money cover with near certainty, and what may not cover it?
  • What does the case say the team does not need to do?
  • Which assumptions does the case name?

A question the team cannot answer goes first on the next meeting’s agenda.

For Mentors and Coaches

  • Give the case a whole session before any trading.
  • Do not summarize it for the team. Your summary becomes their analysis.
  • Ask “Which sentence in the case tells us that?” until students ask it of each other.
  • Put the exit ticket questions to the team at the end of the session. Start the next meeting with the ones it missed.
  • Keep each team’s notes inside that team. Wharton’s rules page bans plagiarism.