Lesson 3
How to Analyze the Case Study
Read a client case in four passes and end with one sentence.
Practice on a Practice Case
- The video teaches the method on a practice case written for teaching. It is not a Wharton case.
- The client is Elias Varnholt, a veterinarian. Elias and every number in his case are invented.
- Wharton’s rules page bans plagiarism. Practice the method on this case, then do your own analysis of your own case.
Start With One Line
- Put the whole case in one line first. Look for the one promise the client has to keep. Every other fact in the case relates to that promise.
- For Elias the line reads: pay his partner $840,000, in cash, on 1 October 2031.
- Then read the case four times, once for each pass.
- Read it as evidence. Skip the story.
Four Passes
| Pass | What to do | What it finds |
|---|---|---|
| The client | Split a page into the facts and what each tells an analyst. | Elias did not sell in the last hard fall, so his willingness to take a loss is high. He says the buyout money cannot come up short, so he cannot afford a loss on it. |
| The money | Put every dollar and every date on one timeline. | $1.1 million now. $40,000 out in August 2027. About $150,000 in from a land sale, no earlier than Year 2 and maybe never. $840,000 out on 1 October 2031. Income from October 2042. |
| The musts | List every sentence with must, required, may not or a high degree of confidence. Count them. | The practice case has eight. Examples: pay in full and on time, and do not count the land money until it arrives. |
| The fences | List everything the case says is not the team’s job. | Valuing the practice and managing his retirement account. Work on those items takes time away from the team’s own job. |
If you cannot point to the sentence, it is not a constraint.
Price the Promise
| Safe rate | Cost today |
|---|---|
| 0 percent | $840,000 |
| 2 percent | $760,800 |
| 3 percent | $724,600 |
| 4 percent | $690,400 |
| 5 percent | $658,200 |
- The safer the team makes the buyout money, the more of the portfolio it takes.
- The case names three assumptions, including 2.5 percent inflation. It gives no safe rate.
- The team picks a rate, defends it, and writes down what changes if it is wrong.
Two Jobs in One Portfolio
- The case never says what the rest of the money is for. The team has to notice.
- This portfolio does two jobs with opposite needs.
- Job one is the buyout money. It must be there, close to certain, in five years. The same bucket holds the $50,000 cash floor and the $40,000 gift to his daughter.
- Job two is the rest. It has sixteen years to grow toward his retirement, so it can take a bad year.
- Lining up safe money against a known payment is called liability matching. Two buckets is a fine name for it too.
The Working Session
- Build the timeline.
- Count the musts and compare lists.
- Price the promise at one safe rate you can defend.
- Draw the buckets at two or three dates, showing how much is already safe money.
- Write the thesis in one sentence.
Thesis shape: Because ___ needs ___ by ___ and can risk ___, we will hold ___ for ___, avoiding ___, because ___.
The Exit Ticket
- How much money goes in, and when?
- What must the money cover with near certainty, and what may not cover it?
- What does the case say the team does not need to do?
- Which assumptions does the case name?
A question the team cannot answer goes first on the next meeting’s agenda.
For Mentors and Coaches
- Give the case a whole session before any trading.
- Do not summarize it for the team. Your summary becomes their analysis.
- Ask “Which sentence in the case tells us that?” until students ask it of each other.
- Put the exit ticket questions to the team at the end of the session. Start the next meeting with the ones it missed.
- Keep each team’s notes inside that team. Wharton’s rules page bans plagiarism.