Lesson 5
How to Write the Trading Notes
One short note for every trade, written on the day.
What a Trading Note Is
- A trading note is a team’s written reason for one decision.
- Wharton’s FAQ asks teams to submit required trading notes and justification. Wharton’s materials give the required format.
- This lesson covers what goes on the page, using the practice client.
- Start notes in week one, before any result exists. Every note becomes material for the Final Report.
Every Trade Answers to the Thesis
- Every note starts from the thesis. The practice thesis splits into five lines.
- He needs $840,000 by October 2031. He can risk only the rest. The buyout money stays safe. No tobacco. The date cannot move.
- When someone proposes a trade, the first question is which line it serves. If the answer is none, the trade does not happen, however good the story sounds.
- Example: a member pitches a large utility. It sounds safe, so the team files it under the buyout money. That is the wrong line.
- A share price can halve in a year, and the buyout money cannot absorb that loss. The utility serves line two, the money he can risk, at a size small enough that a loss cannot break the plan.
Two Portfolios, Two Stories
- The WInS portfolio is not the client’s portfolio. Wharton’s rules page says each team shares one account.
- Wharton’s FAQ calls WInS a valuable learning tool and says standings have little to do with the final outcome.
- WInS is where the team carries out the strategy. It shows what the team bought, at what weight, and which line each position serves.
- A strong simulator record proves the team can carry out a plan. It does not change the client’s plan, which starts from the case figures and the return the team assumed.
- Keep the two stories apart in writing from the first note. One folder for the plan, one for the WInS record.
- The WInS allocation should look like the one the team recommends, at the weights it would actually use.
The Five-Field Note
- What was bought or sold, and at what weight.
- Which line of the thesis it serves.
- What the team believed, and its evidence.
- What would reverse it.
- Later: what happened, and did the thesis change?
Teams skip field four. Insist on it. The team wrote it before it knew how the trade went, so it holds up in December.
A Strong Note and a Weak One
| Field | Strong | Weak |
|---|---|---|
| What | Bought a large utility, 2 percent of the portfolio, growth bucket | Bought a utility |
| Line | Line two: he can risk only the rest | (none) |
| Evidence | Regulated prices, so revenue holds in a bad year, from three annual reports | Solid company, great dividend, very safe |
| Reverse if | The regulator cuts its prices, or the buyout money needs a refill from growth | (nothing) |
| Later | Blank for now | (none) |
The weak note has adjectives, no weight, no line, and nothing that would make the team sell.
The Weekly Review
- From Sept 28, when live trading opens, meet once a week.
- Review the portfolio, pitch new ideas, write down why.
- A week with no trade still gets a note: held, and the reason.
- The review fills field five. If the thesis must change, change it there, in writing, with a dated reason.
Notes and the Reports
- Wharton’s FAQ describes the Final Report as presenting and justifying the team’s strategy, recommendations and analysis. It is due Dec 4.
- A team with notes written on the day and in order, from week one, has done the justifying.
- Where the Final Report differs from the IPS, the notes show when the plan changed and why.
- A note written from memory in December describes a price move and never names a line.
- In 2026 the Trading Notes Analysis asked for three notes from trades the team placed, copied exactly, with a reflection of about 100 words on each.
- A reversed trade with clear reasoning can be a strong pick. The reasoning is what counts.
Check the current instructions for the numbers and the due date.
For Mentors and Coaches
- Stay off the keyboard on trading day. Let the vote stand.
- Suggest roles: a chair, a driver, a note-taker and a strategy lead.
- Ask “Which line of the thesis does this trade serve?” every time. No line, no trade.
- Ask what share of the portfolio a holding is, and what a 50 percent drop would cost.
- Require a source and a date beside every number.