Lesson 5
How to Write the Trading Notes
One short note for every trade, written on the day.
Why Notes Matter
- A note is the team’s reason for one trade, written when it happens.
- It shows judges what students thought before they knew the result.
- The notes feed the October analysis and the December report.
A Five-Field Note
- What and how much.
- Which line of the thesis it serves.
- What the team believes, and the evidence.
- What would make the team reverse it.
- What happened. Fill this in later.
Students skip field four. Insist on it.
Strong and Weak
| Strong | Weak | |
|---|---|---|
| What | Bought a broad bond ETF, 10 percent of the portfolio | Bought a bond fund |
| Why | Steadies the account while payment money moves to Treasuries | Very safe, good choice |
| Reverse if | The payment date moves closer | (nothing) |
A Weekly Review
- Meet once a week during live trading.
- A week with no trade still gets a log line.
- If the thesis changes, change it in writing, with a reason.
The Trading Notes Analysis
- In 2026 teams picked three notes from trades they placed.
- They copied each note exactly and added a reflection of about 100 words.
- A reversed trade with clear reasoning can be a strong pick. The reasoning scores.
Check the current instructions for numbers and due date.
For Mentors and Coaches
- Stay off the keyboard on trading day. Let the vote stand.
- Suggest roles: a chair, a driver, a note-taker and a strategy lead.
- Ask “Which line of the thesis does this trade serve?” every time.
- Ask what share of the portfolio a holding is, and what a 50 percent drop would cost.
- Require a source and a date beside every number.