Skip to content

Wharton Advisor Guide

Lesson 5

How to Write the Trading Notes

One short note for every trade, written on the day.

Why Notes Matter

  • A note is the team’s reason for one trade, written when it happens.
  • It shows judges what students thought before they knew the result.
  • The notes feed the October analysis and the December report.

A Five-Field Note

  1. What and how much.
  2. Which line of the thesis it serves.
  3. What the team believes, and the evidence.
  4. What would make the team reverse it.
  5. What happened. Fill this in later.

Students skip field four. Insist on it.

Strong and Weak

Practice client, holdings named by type only
StrongWeak
WhatBought a broad bond ETF, 10 percent of the portfolioBought a bond fund
WhySteadies the account while payment money moves to TreasuriesVery safe, good choice
Reverse ifThe payment date moves closer(nothing)

A Weekly Review

  • Meet once a week during live trading.
  • A week with no trade still gets a log line.
  • If the thesis changes, change it in writing, with a reason.

The Trading Notes Analysis

  • In 2026 teams picked three notes from trades they placed.
  • They copied each note exactly and added a reflection of about 100 words.
  • A reversed trade with clear reasoning can be a strong pick. The reasoning scores.

Check the current instructions for numbers and due date.

For Mentors and Coaches

  • Stay off the keyboard on trading day. Let the vote stand.
  • Suggest roles: a chair, a driver, a note-taker and a strategy lead.
  • Ask “Which line of the thesis does this trade serve?” every time.
  • Ask what share of the portfolio a holding is, and what a 50 percent drop would cost.
  • Require a source and a date beside every number.